Studies show that we grow up psychologically quite naturally until about the age of twenty. Then, for reasons that are not terribly well understood, we simply stop growing. We remain at whatever psychological level of development we reached in our early twenties until the age of sixty or so, and then we start growing up again.
Very few people actually grow up to the point of self-actualization.
Currently only five percent of the world’s population is self-actualized, "fully" grown, or “awake.”
There are things we can do between the ages of twenty and sixty to ensure we grow up and wake up more fully. We need to do these things to become the very best version of ourselves we can be.
The single most important thing we can do to grow up is to learn about the different developmental levels all humans grow up through. These are called structures of consciousness.
By learning about the structures of consciousness, it helps trigger the psychological growing up process. (The structures become psychoactive in our mind.)
Different developmental psychologists have different names for the structures of consciousness we all grow up through.
I’m going to share Ken Wilber's model with you.
Robert Kegan, an American psychologist from the Harvard Graduate School of Education has an excellent model, too, but I like Wilber’s model the best. I think it’s the easiest to understand.
At the first level of development, survival is our basic priority. Wilber calls this the Infrared or Crimson level. At this level, we can’t easily distinguish where our body starts and our bed stops, for example. We believe that our self is one with the environment. We cannot distinguish our emotions from the emotions of the people around us, particularly our mother. (Emotional distinction happens around 16 months of age. This is when an infant develops a sense of itself as a separate self, and it’s called the psychological birth of the infant.)
Some adults remain at this Infrared level throughout their entire lives. It’s generally because there is some sort of developmental disability, brain damage or difficulty that keeps them at this lower level of development. The elderly who are senile revert to this developmental level as do late-stage Alzheimer’s patients. People who are mentally ill and living on the street sometimes revert to this developmental level, too.
The next level of development is Magenta. This stage begins around the age of two, and this is when we begin to have emotional-feeling capacity. We become in touch with our feelings, but we also become impulsive. A healthy sex drive begins here (yes it’s true) as well as a healthy fantasy life. Instinctual emotions also develop here like anger, lust, and jealousy. If there is a psychological trauma at this stage, it can result in very serious narcissistic and borderline personality disorders because the self’s boundary is so fragile at this stage. Some people remain at this developmental level throughout their entire life.
The next developmental level is Red and it begins around the age of four. At this level we have an emerging attitude or belief that says, “I am distinct from you.” The self at this stage is dominant, impulsive, and egotistical. We enjoy ourselves to the fullest without showing any regret or remorse (think young or aging rock star) and we learn to be conceptual thinkers at this stage. (This is the ability to understand a situation or a problem by identifying patterns or connections.) But mostly we are overly concerned with ourselves, with power, and with our own safety. Our prisons today are full of individuals who are at this egocentric self-protective stage. Gang members are typically at this level as well. They see the world as a very dangerous place full of powerful people, and they want to be powerful, too.
The Amber developmental level is next. It typically begins between the ages of seven and twelve. At this level we can take the role of other (a second-person perspective). We can understand and follow rules. We fit into a group and feel a sense of belonging. We follow a code of conduct based on unwavering absolutes of right and wrong. We believe what our religion tells us absolutely and fundamentally (if we are religious). People at this level believe the Bible, the Quran, or the Talmud literally, not metaphorically. They believe Moses really did part the Red Sea, Elijah really did go to heaven in a chariot, Christ really was born of a biological virgin, and there is no questioning these things. Overall, this is the level of traditional family values and conformist, conventional ethics. This stage is extremely common in adults today. About forty percent of the population of the United States is at this developmental level and about fifty to sixty percent of the world’s population. Rural communities are often at this level, too. The agrarian Midwest in the United States has a very high percentage of fundamentalist believers.
The Orange developmental level is next. It begins in adolescence (if we keep growing up) and now we have the capacity for introspection, self-expression, and self-discovery. We have the ability to step back and view ourselves, and the world objectively. We escape from “herd mentality” in our thinking, and we seek truth and meaning in individualistic terms. We begin to identify with the human race as a whole. We become highly achievement oriented, and we begin to see the world as a rational and well-oiled machine with natural laws that can be learned, mastered, and even manipulated. At this level, we can take a third-person perspective and be objective in our thinking.
The Green stage is next. It begins in adulthood (for those who develop this far) and it brings a great sensitivity to marginalized humans with it. Individuals at this level see every situation has multiple perspectives, and inclusivity becomes important. People become ecologically considerate, more communitarian, and they nurture human bonding. At this stage, people have the power and capacity to rise above third person perspectives, reflect on them, review them, and criticize them. They believe the human spirit must be freed from greed, dogma and divisiveness. They believe feeling is more important than being rational, they cherish the earth, and all life on it, and they emphasize dialogue and relationships. Only about thirty percent of the adult population in Western cultures has reached this developmental level. The industrial northeast of the United States has a high percentage of people at this level. That’s why a majority of the colleges and university like MIT and Harvard are in the northeast. Silicon Valley in California is at this level, too. And many of the baby boomer generation operate from this meme. (Wilber calls the boomer generation an “awakening generation” because of the explosion that occurred in our generation through creativity in technology, ecological sensitivity, political action, lifestyles and music. Maslow called the Green level of development the “beginning” of self-actualization.)
The baby boom generation has a great deal of strengths – we have a willingness to test out new ideas beyond the traditional ones we were raised with, for example – but we also have many weaknesses, and that’s a problem. We tend to be narcissistic and we see ourselves as something pretty special. (Wilber says we see ourselves “as the vanguard of something unprecedented in all of history, the extraordinary wonder of being us.”)
The baby boom generation is stuck at the Green level of psychological development. As a generation, we can’t move forward. We are extremely preoccupied with our narcissistic ways and our very strong drives for materialism. Our lifestyles are overblown and excessive, we don’t adopt truly multicultural views, and meetings are considered a success if everybody gets a chance to express their feelings rather than when a decision is reached. We spent so much time developing our outer world – technology, ecological sensitivity, lifestyles, music etc. – that we neglected our inner world, and we failed to grow and evolve as individuals. (Green is also unhealthy when all kids are given a trophy or certificate just for participating in a sport or an event. This is really dangerous. It actually stunts kids’ growth.)
At Green, we are completely unaware of the interior stages of human development, we cannot grasp the big picture (although we think we can), and we aren’t very inclusive (although we think we are). As a generation, we have not figured out that in order for each of us to be healthy, all of society needs to be healthy.
Today, our culture is completely confused. Us Baby-boomers raised our kids in an atmosphere where there was nothing to believe in, nothing to value, and nothing to aim for so the Millennials turned to the most superficial values left: money and fame. But underneath it all, Millennials have the same burning desire, the same hidden drive, everyone does for real meaning, real worth, real values, real wholeness, real growth and evolution. Millennials simply need to learn how to grow up and wake up. It’s not their fault they didn’t learn this in school. We didn’t teach them how because we didn’t know that we should, or even how to teach it.
The developmental levels from Infrared/Crimson to Green are considered first tier levels, and 95% of the world’s population is in this first tier. Most people are at the Amber level of development (traditional, religious), the Orange level of development (modern, rational, scientific) or the Green level of development (postmodern, pluralistic, multicultural). Only 5% of the world’s population are self-actualized, “fully” grown, or “awake.” When we get to 10% of the population, the world will change rapidly in ways currently beyond our imagination.
Every level of development carries its own sets of values and its own way of seeing the world so Amber, Orange, Green (the most common levels) are at the core of the “culture wars” we hear about on the news. People at these three levels constantly argue because they disagree in their views and values. (If you read the editorial page of any newspaper, you’ll find somebody representing one of these three levels, and they are usually attacking somebody at another level.)
All politicians are at different levels of psychological development, too, some a lot lower than others. The Republican far right in the United States and the Conservative right wing in Canada are Amber in their development. Our education systems are Amber, too. Trump, when he denigrates other cultures and women is actually operating from the Red level of development.
Developmental psychology explains why parents (often Amber or Orange) clash so strongly with their teen-aged children (often Red) and why hippies during the 60s and 70s (Red) clashed with the authorities trying to send them off to the Vietnam War (Amber).
This also explains why there is so much conflict and strife in the world today. People at the first tier level of development think their way of thinking is the “right” way and the “only” way. People in the first tier are dualistic in their thinking, they see themselves as separate and distinct, they don’t view themselves as interconnected parts of an interdependent whole, and they don’t consider what is best for everyone. They only consider what is best for themselves. These people are not aware of the interior stages of development, and they are not able to step back and grasp the bigger picture.
Ninety-five percent of the world's population is at this first tier level of development. And as long as we have 95% of the world’s population at this first tier level, all we’re ever going to get is disharmony and war.
Starting about 30 or 40 years ago, developmental psychologists started spotting the emergence of a new level of development that Wilber calls Turquoise. People at this level make a very big leap in the way they live their lives. They suddenly want to live a life of wholeness, meaning, purpose, and value. They undergo a revolutionary shift in the way they see the world. They no longer operate from the first tier, which is a partial, fragmented, broken, and torn way of seeing the world. They begin to operate from a unified, integrated, and whole perspective, which developmental psychologists call the second tier.
At the second tier, people realize that each of the developmental levels is a necessary ingredient of all subsequent levels (if they know about developmental levels) and they realize that when they transcend one level and move to the next, they transcend and include the old level. People at the second tier begin to realize there is partial truth at every level ,and every level needs to be welcomed, valued, listened to, even celebrated because it’s an important step along the developmental continuum.
At the Turquoise level, people can turn each level or wave “on” as they need it. For example, in emergency situations, they can tap into their Red power drives. During chaotic times, they can activate Amber order. If they are interviewing for a job, they can connect with Orange achievement drives. When they connect with family and friends, they can draw on Green bonding urges. Second tier (turquoise) thinkers are fully aware of the interior stages of development, they are able to step back and grasp the bigger picture, and they are totally inclusive and integrated in their thinking. Second tier thinkers also begin to “show up” in the world. This means they stand up for what they believe in and they work to enact change, even if it means speaking truth to power. This is what showing up looks like: An Open Letter to the Ontario College of Teachers. And this: Former Superintendent Files Human Rights Complaint.
It’s a very big leap to grow developmentally from Green to Turquoise, from the first tier to the second, and after the age of twenty, it doesn't happen on its own. We have to deliberately work at growing up and waking up. The process is actually called growing up, waking up, cleaning up and showing up..
In order to grow up, wake up, clean up and show up past the age of twenty, it’s extremely important we work at it. When we make the big leap from Green to Turquoise, things like war, poverty, discrimination, and ecological destruction of the world don’t make sense any more. We stop ignoring these things, and we devote time and energy toward eradicating them.
When 10% of the population make the big leap from Green to Turquoise, we’ll see big changes in the world. As more and more people grow into the Turquoise level of development, it will become a major leading edge, and the impact on the world will be nothing less than shocking.
But we have to learn about the different developmental levels we all grow up through in order to grow up, wake up, clean up and show up. We must also spend time taking different perspectives. Ultimately, consciousness is the ability to take and see different perspectives. The more perspectives we can take, the more conscious we become. At the higher end of the developmental spectrum, we are able to integrate and take multiple perspectives. Building our capacity to expand our awareness comes with taking the role of "other" regularly. It's much like building our physical muscles.
We also need to practice meditation to help us grow up. Studies show that adults will only move a quarter of one developmental level through exercise, coaching, therapy, or other practices on their own, but when combined with meditation twice a day for four years, adults move an average of two full stages of growth. Meditation is the only technique that’s been demonstrated to grow human beings a full developmental level beyond the age of twenty!
Research also shows that if we combine meditation with yoga (or some other type of energy work like karate or tai chi) and weightlifting, we grow up surprisingly quickly. There is something about meditation, energy work and weightlifting combined that is critical to the growing up and waking up process.
We also have to do shadow work. Shadows are when you see in other people the very thing you yourself have but are unwilling to see in yourself. We have to recognize our shadows, and re-own and re-integrate them instead of denying them or projecting them onto other people. When we re-own and re-integrate our shadows, we eliminate our own negative behaviours.
It's possible to have collective shadows against entire cultures and genders. This is extremely dangerous. When we have collective shadows against other cultures, we vilify them, threaten to build walls, put them in concentration camps, and drop bombs on them. We have to overcome this.
What developmental level are you currently operating from? Self assessment is surprisingly accurate for most people.
Would you like to help bring the world to a more peaceful, loving, and inclusive place? (You can absolutely be part of the growing up, waking up, cleaning up, showing up process if you want.)
In order to participate in this remarkable time in history, learn more about the structures of consciousness, practice taking different perspectives on a daily basis, meditate, do yoga, lift weights, and clean up your shadow elements with professional help if necessary.
Debbie L. Kasman
M. Ed, Policy Studies, OISE/University of Toronto
Education Re-imagined
Analyst & Researcher, Author & Speaker
Follow Debbie on Twitter: @debbiekasman and on Facebook: DebbieLKasman
-
Female Leadership
- Jan 29, 2017 Eight Powerful Reasons You Should Wear a Pink Hat (and do other things to confront gender and racial discrimination) Jan 29, 2017
- Jan 28, 2014 The Power Paradox Jan 28, 2014
-
For Women
- Jan 29, 2017 Eight Powerful Reasons You Should Wear a Pink Hat (and do other things to confront gender and racial discrimination) Jan 29, 2017
- Jan 28, 2014 The Power Paradox Jan 28, 2014
-
Spirituality
- Aug 11, 2023 What Those Working in Ontario's Education System Need To Understand Aug 11, 2023
- Jan 29, 2017 Eight Powerful Reasons You Should Wear a Pink Hat (and do other things to confront gender and racial discrimination) Jan 29, 2017
- Oct 31, 2016 How to Grow Up and Wake Up Between 20 and 60 Years Old Oct 31, 2016
- Apr 1, 2014 The Role of Spirituality in Public Education Apr 1, 2014
- May 30, 2013 Spiral of Existence May 30, 2013
-
Transforming Education
- Aug 11, 2023 What Those Working in Ontario's Education System Need To Understand Aug 11, 2023
- Nov 18, 2022 An Open Letter to Doug Downey Regarding Kayla Lemieux, the Trans Teacher in Oakville, Ontario Nov 18, 2022
- Apr 28, 2022 Chaos at the Thames Valley District School Board - An Open Letter Apr 28, 2022
- Jun 25, 2021 An Open Letter to Dr. Derek Haime, Registrar, Ontario College of Teachers Jun 25, 2021
- Jun 4, 2021 Washington Post issues scathing criticism of Karen Falconer for handling of the Javier Davila situation Jun 4, 2021
- May 3, 2021 Dear Ms. Naylor: Damage control, internal emails, two prominent, stalwart Black community members resign, and what education experts have to say May 3, 2021
- Apr 30, 2021 It's About the Situation in the York Region District School Board Again Apr 30, 2021
- Apr 22, 2021 The York Catholic District School Board is in violation of an Ontario Human Rights Tribunal Order Apr 22, 2021
- Apr 14, 2021 An Open Letter to Nancy Naylor and Patrick Case, Deputy Ministry of Education and Chief Equity Officer, Ministry of Education, Ontario Apr 14, 2021
- Mar 5, 2021 Former superintendent files human rights complaint, alleging “constructive discrimination," after Lecce approves Hofstatter as director of education Mar 5, 2021
- Nov 23, 2020 Education Minister Stephen Lecce is ignoring the Ontario Human Rights Commission, and here’s why Nov 23, 2020
- Sep 24, 2020 An Open Letter to All School Board Trustees in Ontario Sep 24, 2020
- Jul 24, 2020 Ontario government's response to discrimination in education is ineffective and discriminatory Jul 24, 2020
- Jun 21, 2020 Letter to the Ontario Human Rights Commission Jun 21, 2020
- Jun 4, 2020 Dear Director Leclerc - It's About the Hiring You Are About To Do in Light of Peel DSB Directions Jun 4, 2020
- May 28, 2020 Response to 'Ding dong, the witch is gone': Black parents aghast over racist letter to vice-principal force changes at TDSB May 28, 2020
- May 15, 2020 Dear Durham District School Board Teaching Community May 15, 2020
- Apr 28, 2020 An Open Letter to Durham District School Board Trustees Apr 28, 2020
- Sep 6, 2019 An Open Letter to the Canadian School Boards Association Sep 6, 2019
- Nov 15, 2018 Kawartha Pine Ridge District School Board announces first-ever student census while ignoring equity issues Nov 15, 2018
- Nov 12, 2018 Counterpoint: Ontario experience provides ample rationale for axing school boards in Nova Scotia Nov 12, 2018
- Nov 1, 2018 Education Crisis in Ontario: Trustees stay on boards even after issues arise Nov 1, 2018
- Mar 4, 2017 An Open Letter to Premier Kathleen Wynne and Education Minister Mitzie Hunter Mar 4, 2017
- Feb 6, 2017 Three Hidden Ways Education Contributes to Discrimination Feb 6, 2017
- Oct 31, 2016 How to Grow Up and Wake Up Between 20 and 60 Years Old Oct 31, 2016
- Apr 1, 2014 The Role of Spirituality in Public Education Apr 1, 2014